Beyond The First Move Conditions For Enduring Advantage On The Moon

Title: Beyond The First Move Conditions For Enduring Advantage On The Moon
Format: Conference
Publication Date: October 2026
Published In: International Astronautical Congress 2026
Publisher International Astronautical Federation
Description:

As leaders from the U.S. space enterprise continue to voice their growing concerns over the prospect of China reaching the lunar south pole before the United States does, the question of which state will be first to establish a sustained human presence on the Moon has taken on renewed strategic significance. While the idea of attaining a certain first-mover advantage has dominated the discourse, no study has yet explored whether a rapid arrival to the Moon is a necessary step in securing an enduring advantage in that domain. This paper begins by reviewing existing scholarship on first-mover advantage to identify the specific set of benefits that an early arrival can provide on the lunar south pole. It then assesses the extent to which a first arrival may contribute to an enduring advantage, hypothesising that the larger the temporal gap between the arrival of the first and the second mover and the higher the rate of operational expansion, the greater the likelihood of acquiring a lasting advantage. We then test these hypotheses by running a series of Monte Carlo simulations using the Lunar Policy Sandbox, a digital tabletop simulator built on data from the LROC QuickMap; to model competition between two actors vying to establish and expand operations at the lunar south pole. We find that while arriving first provides significant benefits, it does not ultimately secure an enduring advantage on the Moon. Instead, attaining an enduring advantage will depend on the ability of a given actor to maintain a sufficient rate of operational expansion. As cislunar activities continue to increase and as more actors enter the lunar d​o​

Ivan Allen College Contributors:
External Contributors: Lauren Victoria Paulson, Thomas Smith
Citation:

Miranda España, F., Paulson, L. V., Smith, T., & González Roberts, T. (2026, October). Beyond the First Move: Conditions for Enduring Advantage on the Moon. Paper presented at the International Astronautical Congress (IAC 2026).

Categories:
  • Globalization: Political Economy and Governance
  • International Security Policy
  • Science, Technology, and International Policy
Related Departments:
  • Sam Nunn School of International Affairs